It is hard to evaluate the success of a small, grassroots
program like Project Piaxtla--especially when it comes
to gauging its contribution to long-term social change,
which is the ultimate determinant of health. Piaxtla
and the organization of poor farmers that grew out of
it have sparked a process of empowerment which has had
a limited but significant impact locally. Child mortality
has declined to 20% of what it was when the program
began. Despite a drop in real wages in Mexico as a whole,
extreme poverty in the program's area of coverage is
less common than it used to be. The gap between rich
and poor in the distribution of land, wealth, and power
has narrowed substantially. And the people's election
to conserve their ejido status for the time
being helps make their gains in land and health more
sustainable.
But the Piaxtla team knows it is playing with fire.
The government has made several attempts to shut down
the villager-run program. Members of the Piaxtla team
and of the organization of poor farmers have been jailed
and threatened. The government has also tried to put
Piaxtla out of business by starting its own rival health
services in the area (instead of turning its attention
to the many areas of Mexico which are still without
health services). Paradoxically, however, while the
government clinic has seriously weakened Piaxtla's actual
health service (which is currently in disarray) it has
also freed the program's most motivated health workers
to focus on addressing the more basic social, economic,
and political causes of poor health. In the final analysis,
the Piaxtla team's work in these areas has done far
more to reduce child mortality and improve people's
health--and overall quality of life--than a narrow medical
approach alone could have accomplished.
Now in the 1990s, the villagers recognize that the
future is less certain than ever. They foresee that
the improvements in health won through years of community
organizing and struggle may be lost tomorrow due to
greed-driven global policies. They have seen the constitution
that their forefathers fought for violated by foreign
powers in conspiracy with their own self-seeking leaders.
For them, the "free trade" agreement is not free; it
has cost them their land, their health, their most basic
human rights, and the dignity of self-determination.
The plight of poor farming and working people in Mexico
is not an isolated situation. Similar hardships are
being wrought on disadvantaged peoples in every corner
of today's endangered planet. The global power structure--comprised
of big government, big business, and the international
financial institutions--has imposed its New World Order
worldwide. It has tied most areas of production and
development to the global market in a way that benefits
powerful interests and weakens the bargaining power
of the poor. Today no nation--and, indeed, virtually
no village--has the liberty of self-determination.