| |
Newsletter from the Sierra Madre #34
December 1996
(sólo Inglés)
Project PROJIMO: a program run by and
for disabled young persons in western Mexico
Project Piaxtla: a villager-run health care network in the
mountains of western Mexico
In this Newsletter we describe a brief training course in Community-Based
Rehabilitation in Recife, Brazil. Concentrating on practical activities,
participants helped improve the situation of disabled children in distressing
conditions--in part by arranging for mentally handicapped girls to help
care for physically disabled children. Here we also announce two new books
developed through HealthWrights. The first is Questioning the Solution:
The Politics of Primary Health Care and Child Survival, which is just
off the press. The second, which will be in print in 1997, is Nothing
About Us Without Us: Developing Innovative Technologies For, By, and With
Disabled Persons. Sample pages from this forthcoming book are included
as a preview.
A Hands-on Learning Event in Brazil forMultipliers
of Community-Based Rehabilitation-- David Werner --Striking
contrasts in Brazil
Brazil is a vast country which does not tolerate--but celebrates--DIFFERENCE.
With its warmly human yet seductively candid vitality, the country is
less a melting pot than a motley collage of races and cultures. A diversity
of tropical, temperate, and 'cool' personalities--black, indigenous, caucasian--convive
with daunting variations of harmony and discord while passionately preserving
ethnic roots and rites. <
Brazil has striking contrasts and contradictions. Its history is shrouded
by colonial exploitation, the slave trade, brutal military dictatorships,
and currently, by a voracious market economy that is further widening
the immense gap between rich and poor. Today Brazil is one of the most
inequitable countries on the planet: its wealthiest 10% have earnings
32 times that of the poorest 20%; festering favelas surround the heavily
fortressed, prison-like palaces of the rich; the diseases of over-consumption
divert public attention from the overwhelming diseases of poverty.
Because of these enormous injustices, Brazil has been the spawning ground
for a spectrum of idealistic social movements and democratic struggles.
Through its comunidades de base (communities of poor families based on
Biblical caring and sharing), Brazil pioneered the Theology of Liberation.
While in Recife I had the privilege to meet 85-year-old former-Bishop
Helder Camara, the beloved "pastor of the poor." Long one of
my heroes, I still have a quote by Camara pinned over my desk in California.
It reads:
"When I give food to the poor they call me a saint.
When I ask why the poor have no food, they call me a communist."
Brazil is also the birthplace of the renowned educator, Paulo Freire.
During the military dictatorship, he launched an adult literacy program
which, through a group process he called conscientizaçao, so effectively
raised the awareness of destitute citizens that Freire was jailed and
then exiled. (He is now once again a national celebrity.) <
Freire's methodology of 'education for liberation'--described in his
classic book Pedagogy of the Oppressed--has been adapted for health promotion
throughout Latin America and the world to help communities analyze and
organize to correct the root causes of poverty and poor health. In the
village health program in Mexico we have made good use of Freire's methods.
Our guidebook Helping Health Workers Learn devotes a chapter to Freire's
empowering methodology.
Today Brazil no longer has a military dictatorship; its leaders are elected.
But still the government is full of contradictions. While it promotes
certain policies to soften the hardships of the disadvantaged, it caters
mostly to the interests of the wealthy and powerful, often at devastating
human and environmental cost.
Fighting for disability rights in Brazil: from the bottom
up and the top down
To a large extent, improvements in the rights of disadvantaged persons
in Brazil have been achieved through organized, sometimes militant, popular
demand. For disabled persons, a strong Independent Living (IL) movement
has grown up in the larger towns and cities. Together with parent associations
and organizations of persons with different disabilities, it has successfully
pressured for the passage of laws to protect the rights and enhance opportunities
of disabled persons.
Fortunately, Brazil currently has a progressive branch of the Ministry
of Justice, called CORDE (Coordination for the Integration of Disabled
Persons) which welcomes input from disability organizations. In the last
few years, CORDE has taken growing interest in promoting Community-Based
Rehabilitation nationwide. In 1995, CORDE held a Technical Seminar on
CBR, to which I was invited. CORDE has recently published the first Portuguese
edition of Disabled Village Children. (The translation was organized by
our friend Gene Williams, a disabled activist from Massachusetts who has
worked closely with the IL movement in Brazil.)
A Course for 'Multipliers' of Community-Based Rehabilitation
From October 28 to November 1, 1996, CORDE invited me to Brazil to teach
a "Course for Multipliers of Community-Based Rehabilitation (CBR)"
in the northern coastal city of Recife. The text for the course was Disabled
Village Children.
When first asked to teach the 5-day course, I had misgivings. The 60 participants
(too many for a fully participatory process) were to be government workers
active in some sort of rehabilitation or disability-related work. Required
to have "at least 3 years of community experience," they were
selected from two dozen municipalities of Northeastern Brazil. After graduating
from the 5-day course they were expected to become the trainers and multiplicadores,
promoting CBR at the community level.
I confess I had serious doubts about such an apparently top-down, government-initiated
approach to CBR. In my experience (and I have visited many community programs
in different countries), the most successful and sustainable CBR programs
are usually started from below by those who are most concerned: groups
of disabled persons and families of disabled children. For this reason
I requested that the course include (1) a substantial number of disabled
participants (or family members) some of whom should be disabled organization
leaders and activists, (2) home visits and discussions with willing, local
disabled persons/families living in difficult circumstances, to get their
perspective on needs, obstacles, wishes, and ideas for program priorities,
and (3) hands-on, problem-solving activities with disabled children and
their families, including construction of assistive devices using low-cost
local aids designed for and with the individual child. I felt that if
the course could help rehabilitation professionals to work together with
communities, listen to disabled persons, and relate to them as partners
and equals in the problem solving process, much might be accomplished.
The goal should be to encourage rehabilitation workers to empower, not
merely to prescribe.
Course preparations. I arrived in Recife several
days before the course, in order to make plans with the local coordinator.
I also wanted to meet with leaders of disability groups and with families
of disabled children in difficult circumstances to arrange their involvement
as resource persons in the course. One of our visits was to a government-run
institution: a hostel for abandoned, severely disabled children. For me
this visit was deeply disturbing. I witnessed institutionalized cruelty
to helpless children. Though unintentional, this cruelty had become routine
and almost acceptable. It stemmed from shortage of personnel, budgetary
limitations, official bureaucracy, and the distance of decision-makers
from the children affected. The result was to increase, rather than reduce,
the children's disability.
The 60 children in this hostel--many with multiple disabilities--are
usually cared for by an average of 5 or 6 caretakers at any one time.
Several appeared to be chronically starving.
Tiny for their age, they were skin and bones. Their severe wasting (marasmus)
was not due to food scarcity but to difficulty with head-control and trouble
swallowing. They could take only liquid foods in small sips. To prevent
gagging they needed to be correctly positioned and gently spoon fed. Getting
enough food into them to satisfy their calorie needs (and hunger) would
require a lot of time and patience. The children's caretakers--including
nurses and social workers--were loving women who did their best. But with
so many multiply disabled children to try to feed, keep clean, and care
for, the few caretakers simply did not have the time to adequately feed
and mother those children who needed extra help. As a result the neediest
children were emaciated and stunted. Apart from a food deficit, they got
much less hugging and stimulation than they needed for their minds and
bodies to grow. Given the chronic shortage of personnel, even the pediatrician,
psychologist, and therapists who regularly visited the program saw no
clear solution. The children's situation was stoically accepted as unfortunate
but inevitable. Notwithstanding, these youngsters at least have roofs
over their heads and someone to provide a bit of care for them--unlike
most of Brazil's millions of hungry street kids.
On arriving at this hostel, we were shown a dozen disabled children lined
up on the porch, all sitting in special wheeled seats, or strollers. All
the strollers were exactly the same, regardless of the size, spastic patterns,
or individual needs of the children. Their canvas seats were held by diagonal
metal-tube frames. The children sat passively in a half-reclining position,
like sacks of potatoes.
Not only were the stroller-seats failing to provide good positioning
or stimulate head and body control, for many of the children the unhealthy
positioning was leading to increased spasticity and deformity. A few of
the less severely disabled children were able to take a few steps with
assistance, but they had no walkers. The one walker we saw was inappropriate
and broken.
Given these children's extensive unmet needs, it occurred to me that--with
some guidance and the use of their books (Disabled Village Children)--the
participants in the training course might be able to make simple, individually
adapted seats, assistive devices, and stimulating play-things for some
of the children. With the help of the staff, we chose 6 children whom
they agreed to take to a workshop to be conducted during the course.
The course. Despite my misgivings, the training
course was a success. There were a lot of practical, hands-on activities.
Divided into small groups, the participants had a chance to meet and talk
with parents of disabled children, and--whenever possible--with the children
themselves. The disabled participants in the course, many of whom were
leaders of disabled organizations, provided a key dynamic. They led discussions
about needs and possibilities based on their own experiences.
One day was spent mostly on Child-to-Child activities. In the morning,
after watching a slide show from Mexico to spark their imaginations, the
course participants first practiced Child-to-Child activities among themselves.
They used simulation games, role-plays, and discussions designed to sensitize
school-age children to the needs and potential of children who are different.
In the afternoon, small groups of participants went into various classrooms
of a public school. After some ice-breaking games, they facilitated similar
activities with the children. The school kids were at first shy. But once
they discovered that the adults actually listened to them and took their
ideas seriously, the kids warmed up. They expressed their own doubts and
fears concerning disabled persons, acted out role-plays, and asked perceptive
questions. At the end of the sessions the course participants asked the
kids how they liked the activities, and what they felt they had learned.
What they said they liked most was the chance to talk openly and directly
with some of the disabled participants, some of whom were blind, quadriplegic,
or had undeveloped limbs or other marked deformities. The students said
that the activities had helped them realize that disabled people are ordinary
people like themselves, with the same needs, emotions, and dreams.
The appropriate technology workshop. Two half-days
of the course (one afternoon and the next morning) were spent in a small
wheelchair-making workshop run by physically disabled youth in a low-income
neighborhood of Recife. The course coordinators and I had visited this
workshop before the course started, to talk with the workers about our
objectives and to request their assistance. We had explained that we hoped
to bring several disabled children from the government hostel (described
above), so that in the workshop the course participants could evaluate
the children's needs and attempt to make simple, individually-designed
assistive devices for each child. The disabled shop-workers were eager
to help in whatever ways they could.
I had my doubts about whether a workshop with so many (60) participants--most
of them inexperienced with innovative, low-cost technologies--could work
without becoming total chaos. I also worried that with so many adults
milling about in a small, hot, non-air-conditioned workshop, the situation
might be overwhelming for the disabled children, especially for those
who were undernourished and in delicate health.
But my fears were soon calmed. The participants formed 6 groups, each
with a bewildered disabled child. But among the participants were many
educators, child psychologists, physical and occupational therapist, rehabilitation
technicians, disabled persons, and--most important of all--mothers of
disabled children. The different groups pooled their resources and rose
to the occasion. The mothers first tried to gain the children's confidence,
talking gently to them, and then gently beginning to touch the children
and take them into their arms. The children, starved for attention and
human contact, began to smile and respond. A couple of the course participants
with experience in evaluating children's needs and designing assistive
equipment assisted me in circulating from group to group. At first most
of the participants were afraid to rely on their own observations, and
to innovate. But the children's needs were so enormous that the groups
began to improvise. The disabled shop workers--whose experience was mainly
with construction of metal wheelchairs and walkers--rose to the occasion
and began working on innovative designs themselves, in addition to assisting
the different groups when their skills were needed.
The end results in the workshop were impressive. Using cardboard, sticks,
strips of cloth, and occasional bits of metal bar or tubing, the groups
managed to create a variety of quite functional assistive devices for
the children, including special seats, wheelchair inserts and supports
for improved body position and head control, a hand splint to improve
manual function, tray tables, and a variety of colorful toys, which were
suspended above a child for stimulation and development of hand-eye coordination.
To all appearances, the children appreciated both the attention and the
equipment. The staff from the hospital, who accompanied the children,
were thrilled by the discovery that important assistive devices could
be so easily and simply made. They said that they would make equipment
for other children at the institution, and were delighted to receive a
copy of Disabled Village Children to provide ideas and guidelines.
A survival seat for Enrique. Perhaps the most
important--and potentially life-saving--assistive devices created by the
course participants at the workshop were the seats and seat inserts that
helped position children's bodies and heads so that it would make swallowing
and feeding them easier.
One of the children whose needs were most critical was Enrique. Physically
completely paralyzed by brain damage at birth, Enrique had been abandoned
by his poverty-stricken parents and eventually ended up at the government
hostel. Skin and bones, he looked about 6 years old, but we were told
he was 14. Feeding him was a big problem, since his body and head were
completely floppy, and he had no mouth control. Although unable to move
or speak, Enrique's mental ability was apparently intact. However, his
only way to communicate was with his eyes. He seemed to understand most
questions, and would close his eyes to say no, and leave them open to
say yes. Sometimes he almost seemed to smile. And sometimes, when asked
questions about the special seat his group was making for him, tears would
roll down his cheeks. He appeared to like both the seat and the attention,
but would weep with frustration at not being able to communicate more
effectively. The participants realized that while they were perhaps able
to help Enrique in a small way--and at least make feeding him easier for
his care-providers--a lot remained undone. Enrique needed a real home,
a loving family, public assistance, and community support.
"And how many other children like Enrique are there in Brazil?"
asked one course participant, tears in her eyes.
Juao the shop worker. One of the young workers
in the wheelchair-making shop had one leg paralyzed by polio and walked
by pushing on his weak thigh with his hand.
He wanted to know if anything could be done so he could walk without having
to push with his hand (which made carrying large objects more difficult).
A group of course participants was assigned to help Juao resolve his problem.
The group was encouraged to work with Juao as an equal in the problem-solving
process, and not simply to design and make an assistive device for him.
"Work with him as a partner, not a patient!"
Examining Juao's leg, the group found that he had a knee contracture
of about 25 degrees, which, if possible, needed to be corrected before
Juao could walk with a brace. They performed a test to find out whether
the contracture was primarily in the muscles or in the knee itself. (If
in the muscles, the contracture can often be corrected with exercise,
casting, or bracing, to gradually stretch the tight muscles. If the contracture
is in the joint capsule, surgery may be required.) To explain all this
to Juao, the group used a life-size plywood skeleton made in PROJIMO (the
community rehabilitation program with which I work in Mexico). The skeleton
has 'muscles,' made from old bicycle inner-tubes, which stretch and contract
as the joints move. This is an excellent teaching aid for demystifying
basic anatomy. Juao enjoyed the skeleton act, and said it helped him to
understand the functions of his knee.
The group decided that the first step toward improving Juao's walking
was to gradually correct his knee contracture with a night brace. Among
the course participants was an orthotist (professional brace maker) who
helped Juao's group design a simple leg brace which they could make from
two long flat metal bars joined by curved sections of metal tube (materials
that were available in the wheelchair shop). Juao was the only person
in his group with the metal-working skills needed for making the brace.
But when the group of professionals started working, the predictable thing
happened. Juao was left lying on the examining table, while the others
began to cut, measure, and attempt to bend the pieces for the brace. Juao
watched passively without comment. Then suddenly, one of the disabled
participants woke up and said, "Hey! Juao is more skilled at metal-work
than we are. And he knows more about his own leg. Rather than our making
the brace for him, he should be making it himself, with our help. That
way, if he has to adjust or remake it after we are gone, he'll know how."
Everyone agreed. With a grin, Juao climbed off the table and took charge.
Opening a copy of Disabled Village Children, the group showed him drawings
of similar braces.
Juao did an excellent job making the brace. Everyone learned a great
deal. But the most important lesson they learned was that of working with
the disabled person as a partner and not a patient. This is the key to
Community-Based Rehabilitation.
Child-to-Child: Mentally handicapped girls care for multiply
disabled children.
The participants in the course were deeply concerned about the inadequate
care that the disabled children at the hostel were receiving. They realized
that the women at the hostel were far too overworked. "The hostel
desperately needed more staff, more help! Children are starving because
they don't have enough attendants to feed them! But what can be done?
In the present economic climate, the government consistently cuts back
on budgets for public services, even as the need grows. What to do?"
Then an idea came for a possible solution. Next to the government hostel
for multiply disabled children is another hostel for orphaned and abandoned
mentally handicapped girls. Indeed, both hostels are part of the same
institution, although managed separately. The girls are cared for in small
group homes, and are taught to be as self sufficient as possible. Some
of them read and write and attend normal school (a big step forward).
They are also taught work skills. But finding employment is difficult.
And because many of the girls have no place to go as they get older, they
continue living in the hostel with little direction or purpose in their
lives.
A solution to the dilemma of both hostels was evident. One hostel was
desperately in need of more staff to help hold, hug, and feed the multiply
disabled children.
The other hostel had a group of mentally handicapped girls who needed
activities to give them a sense of worth. The 2 hostels were separated
only by a high wire gate. Why not unlock it? Why not invite the older,
more capable mentally handicapped girls to help care for the severely
disabled children. The latter needed mothering; the girls longed to be
maternal. Much of the care needed for the multiply disabled children required
more time and patience than skill. They needed holding, hugging, loving,
simple exercises, bathing, and above all, food. Wasn't this the kind of
meaningful occupation that many of these mentally slow girls were longing
for?
Following up on this suggestion, on the second day of the workshop the
coordinators of the government hostel brought one of the older, more able
girls along with the 6 children. The girl, Maria, was excited and eager
to help. One of the course participants, the mother of a disabled child
herself, helped show Maria how to hold and handle a younger girl who had
cerebral palsy and almost no body control. Maria soon learned how to position
the younger child in her new special seat. Then another participant, a
physiotherapist, showed Maria how to help the child begin to develop head
control by holding her upright by the shoulders and gently supporting
the back of her head with her hands.
Follow-up. The most important outcome of the workshop, perhaps, was not
the equipment made, but the prospects for improving the care for the disabled
children in the government institution. Several of the participants who
lived in Recife offered to make regular visits to the hostel to trouble-shoot
problems and to try to find solutions. An exceptional physiotherapist
agreed to work with the staff of the hostel to continue teaching Maria
and other mentally handicapped girls how to feed, provide exercise, and
care for the younger children. Another course participant, Father Eduardo
Figueroa, also agreed to counsel, assist, and if possible, find additional
funding for the hostel. Father Eduardo runs a family home for 50 abandoned
children, 9 of whom are disabled. Although some of Father Eduardo's children
are extensively and multiply disabled (one is paralyzed, deaf, and blind),
all are well fed and very much loved and cared for. Most importantly,
the older and more able children take pleasure and pride in caring for
and teaching the younger ones. It is Child-to-Child at its best. Father
Eduardo's assistance at the hostel will be an enormous help.
Final evaluation. The course for multipliers of CBR finished with an
evaluation by the participants. All felt that they had learned a lot.
Some persons' remarks were moving.
As one rehabilitation center coordinator spoke of her experience with
Enrique, she burst into tears. "I didn't know there were children
like this in Brazil," she lamented. "So starved, so neglected,
and in our own official institutions. I'll never forget the tears in little
Enrique's eyes when he so much wanted to tell us something, and could
not." She wiped her eyes. "But somehow I guess he told us a
lot."
At the end of the evaluation, a blind participant stood up and said,
"We have learned something about Community-Based Rehabilitation.
But we have learned a lot more. We have learned that what disabled activist,
Joshua Malinga, said is true: 'It is society that needs to be rehabilitated.'
Brazil is a wealthy country. We have enough resources to meet everyone's
needs, to provide a roof and food and health care for all. Yet there are
5 million homeless kids on the streets. Not far from this 5-star hotel
in which we have been meeting there are famished, disabled beggars picking
through garbage heaps. We who are disabled, and we who work for and with
disabled people, need to stand up for the rights of all hungry and disadvantaged
people, to fight for a society where people are more equal, in which no
one grows fat while others starve. It is our society that needs to be
rehabilitated. This is what should be meant by Community-Based Rehabilitation."
Everyone stood up and applauded. The course was over.Announcing a New
Video and GuidebookChild-to-Child: at the roots of health
Nominated "Best Community Health Video of 1996" by the American
Medical Association, Child-to-Child: at the roots of health takes viewers
to Mexico where Child-to-Child has developed into a fun-filled process
that empowers children to identify the problems affecting their health
and well-being. Utilizing Child-to-Child activities, children analyze
the root causes of poor health and take collective action to protect the
health and well-being of themselves, their families and their communities.
Activities demonstrated in the 17 minute video address dehydration, diarrheal
disease, measles, pollution, and disability. An 80 page companion guidebook
details Child-to-Child as practiced in Mexico. The guidebook also provides
a case study in Chicago demonstrating its versatility with examples dealing
with different types of problems, such as drugs, gangs and alcohol abuse.
For more information, or to order the video and guidebook, please contact
Peterson Productions, PO Box 617, Tiburon, CA 94920 USA, FAX 415-435-5321,
or Phone 415-435-0332. Mention Newsletter from the Sierra Madre and receive
a 10 percent discount.
A Forthcoming Book by David Werner, HealthWrights, and PROJIMO:NOTHING
ABOUT US WITHOUT USDEVELOPING INNOVATIVE TECHNOLOGIES FOR, BY, AND WITH
DISABLED PERSONS
A companion to DISABLED VILLAGE CHILDREN. This exciting new book is scheduled
for release in early 1997 and will be a companion to David Werner's previous
book, Disabled Village Children, which has become one of the most widely
used Community-Based Rehabilitation guide-books worldwide.
50 stories. Unlike Disabled Village Children,
however, Nothing About Us Without Us is more of a storybook than a guidebook.
Its purpose is not merely to instruct, but to transform, to awaken readers--especially
disabled persons and those working with them--to new, exciting possibilities.
The book consists of 50 true stories, from Project PROJIMO (a world-renowned
CBR program in western Mexico) and around the world, which stress one
important theme:
Assistive devices and techniques for disabled persons tend to work better
and be more empowering when the disabled user takes the lead-- and when
he or she is involved as a partner and equal in the problem-solving process.
Although this is a book about innovating assistive devices and user-centered
approaches to meeting needs, it differs from other manuals in that it
puts the person and the process before the product. With the help of hundreds
of line drawings and photos, the book covers a wide range of innovative
equipment that can be made with local materials at the village or community
level. In presenting each innovation, it places emphasis not so much on
the end-product (however important) as on the collaborative process of
discovery.
User-centered. Nearly every example in this book, starts by looking at
a disabled individual--often a child. With that person central to the
problem-solving process, we explore his or her unique combination of wishes
and needs. We describe the cooperative, trial-and-error methods used in
designing solutions to meet those needs. The problem-solving process is
open-ended and ongoing. Sometimes it entails learning new skills, sometimes
it involves modification of environment, and sometimes it leads to the
invention, adaptation, or elimination of an assistive device. Creative
adventure is key.
This new book is organized into an introduction and 4 sections:
INTRO: DISABLED PERSONS AS LEADERS IN THE
PROBLEM-SOLVING PROCESS
PART 1: THE PURPOSE OF SPECIAL SEATING: FREEDOM
AND DEVELOPMENT, NOT CONFINEMENT
PART 2: CREATIVE SOLUTIONS TO PERSONAL AND
SITUATIONAL NEEDS
PART 3: FREEDOM ON WHEELS: DESIGNING MOBILITY
AIDS TO MEET INDIVIDUAL NEEDS
PART 4: INNOVATIVE METHODS AND APPROACHES:
PEOPLE HELPING AND LEARNING FROM EACH
OTHER AS EQUALS
PART 5: CHILD-TO-CHILD ACTIVITIES THAT INCLUDE AND EMPOWER DISABLED CHILDREN
Nothing About Us Without Us. 320 pages. Hundreds of photos and drawings.
Pre-publication price: $12.00 plus postage.
If interested in obtaining a copy when available in 1997,
contact:
HealthWrights
964 Hamilton Avenue
Palo Alto, CA 94301, USA
Fax: 415 325-1080; Tel: 415 325-7500
email: healthrights@igc.apc.orgThe following are samples
from three chapters from Nothing About Us Without Us: Developing Innovative
Technologies For, By and With Disabled Persons
Using Spasticity for Independent Living
Through experimentation Julio has learned to use his spasticity
to be more self-reliant, despite his paralyzed hand and weak arms. He
has also developed strong shoulder muscles to help compensate for his
weak arms.
Julio Teaches Daily Living Skills to Another Quadriplegic
Youth
Romeo was working as an 'illegal alien' in the
USA to send money to his ailing mother back home. He became quadriplegic
in a car accident. After 3 months in a hospital he was sent back to Mexico.
On his arrival at PROJIMO, Julio quickly became his friend, role model
and tutor. In California a nurse had given Romeo a 'transfer board' for
moving from wheelchair to bed. But within 2 days at PROJIMO, Julio taught
him to move to and from his wheelchair without help and without a transfer
board.Then Romeo followed Julio's example.
Having a capable person with the same disability as a teacher
made learning easier.Both Julio and Romeo benefitted greatly.
Four children with Muscular Dystrophy Lead a
Program for Disabled Children The Peraza family lives in
a poor neighborhood of Mazatlan city. When the parents realized that four
of their children had a disabling condition, they were determined to do
everything possible for them. At that time in Mazatlan it was impossible
to get significantly disabled children into the public schools. So they
created their own school. With the help of an exceptional social worker,
Teresa Paez, the Perazas met with families of other disabled children
in the community and determined to start their own education and rehabilitation
program for their children. They called themselves Los Pargos, the name
of a local fish which the elite consider inferior.
Los Pargos was organized as a cooperative, of which the disabled
children and their parents were participating members. Most of the families
were quite poor. To raise money for school supplies and transportation,
the families made colorful trinkets to sell. Outstanding among these were
artificial flowers and ornaments, made mostly out of fish scales. Parents
and children would go on 'work picnics' to the seashore, where fishermen
cleaned fish. They collected sackfuls of fish scales, washed and sun dried
them, stained them different colors, and glued them together into delicate
flowers and bouquets.
All four of the Peraza siblings became gifted artists and craftspersons.
But the most outstanding was Sósimo. Like the other Pargitos, Sósimo had
a fascination with the ocean and its creatures. One of his most haunting
paintings is a portrait of a woman in the bottom of the ocean. After Sósimo
had died, his sister Dinora told me he had painted it "because when
people die they go to the bottom of the ocean and that is what makes the
waves."
Eventually, over a period of several years, one after the
other of the three Peraza brothers died from pulmonary complications.
(Now only their sister, Dinora, is alive). It was amazing what these four
youth with muscular dystrophy managed to accomplish, and the pride and
joy they took in doing it while their physical condition gradually deteriorated.
For all their creativity and problem-solving skills, they could not halt
the progress of the disease. But the dignity, caring, and leadership skills
they developed and shared with their peers lives on.
Appropriate Paper-based Technology (APT)
Most of the special seats described in this book have been
made at fairly low cost with wood or plywood. But for many families even
local wood is too expensive, or hard to obtain. For this reason, in Zimbabwe,
Africa, many years ago an elderly man named Bevill Packer began to make
special seating and other assistive devices out of waste paper and cardboard.
In this Appropriate Paper-based Technology, layers of paper and/or cardboard
are glued together with paste made from flour and water. Paste can even
be made from left-over 'sadza,' a flour porridge widely used as a weaning
food. When well made, these paper-based seating aids and other devices
can be unbelievably strong.
Apart from low-cost (in terms of materials), paper-based
technology has other advantages:
- Easy and fun to make. Young children can take part in
making the equipment. (However, considerable care with technique is
needed for the results to be strong and durable.)
- Very adaptable to personal needs. Seat-backs and various
supports can be molded to meet the needs of the individual child. Similarly,
adjustments can be made, hollows scooped out, or protrusions (lumps)
added where needed for added comfort, protection, or support.
Gentle touch. Especially when the main structures are made
of corrugated cardboard (as used in many 'thick wall' cardboard boxes)
the resultant seat or device has a surface that is somewhat flexible.
This provides a softer, more giving, more personal touch and is gentler
where it comes in contact with knees, butt bones, and other bony areas.
Thus it tends to be more comfortable and protective (against pressure
sores) than wood, plastic, or metal.
Cruz is a 2 year old boy with a type of cerebral palsy that
ranges between floppy (low muscle tone) and spastic (uncontrolled tightening
of muscles). His mother loves him dearly and devotes a lot of time to
helping him develop his body, mind, and spirit to their best potential.
Cruz's brothers and sisters also enjoy playing with him, talking to him,
and helping him with activities. Thanks to this loving family effort,
Cruz has gained fairly good head control, and with difficulty manages
to open his hands to wave hello and goodbye. He is learning to sit with
the help of sandbags across his folded knees and against his hips. He
also tries very hard to speak. Although his words are hard to understand,
his family has learned to interpret them, and encourages him to speak
as much as possible. The boy thrives on all the hugging, handling, and
encouragement he receives.
A wooden seat the child hated. Cruz's mother brought the
boy to PROJIMO from a village about 15 miles away. In a dynamic interchange
of ideas and experience, the rehabilitation workers learned as many practical
developmental activities from his mother as they were able to teach her.
It was agreed that Cruz might benefit from a special seat. Juan designed
and built a handsome plywood seat for him, complete with a removable backrest
so that, when the backrest was removed, Cruz would need to use his back
and trunk muscles to sit upright.
But for some reason Cruz hated his wooden seat. Though usually
cheerful, whenever he was placed in the seat, he began to scream and wail.
His mother was sure he would get used to it, but after two months he still
refused to accept it.
A cardboard seat he liked. Because at this time PROJIMO was
experimenting with paper-based technology, they tried sitting Cruz in
an uncompleted seat made of laminated corrugated cardboard. To everyone's
amazement, he was all laughs and smiles. His mother was amazed at the
difference.
We are not sure why Cruz--who had such a strong dislike for
the plywood seat--took an instant liking to the cardboard one. The positioning
and support provided by each was much the same. We suspect that the cardboard
seat--with its thick, rounded, relatively soft, yielding structures--was
somehow friendlier and more similar to human touch. By contrast, the plywood
seat, even with its cushioned lining, was more rigid and unyielding; despite
the smiling rabbits painted on its sides, it was not as child-friendly.
A cardboard seat was built to meet Cruz's particular needs.
At the front of the seat a removable post, or pummel, was placed to keep
the boy from slipping forward. A large table top fit low around the boy's
waist, to help stabilize his lower trunk. A removable, U-shaped hip support
fit into the seat, to help stabilize his hips and to hold him slightly
forward from the seat back. That way, when he chose, he could sit upright
without leaning against the seat back. (The idea for this U-shaped hip
support came from watching Cruz's mother place sand bags around his hips
to help him sit upright.)
All the parts of the seat--including the table top, pummel,
and U-shaped hip support--were made by laminating (pasting together) layers
of corrugated cardboard cut from old cartons. On trial, Cruz sat fairly
well in the seat. But there were some problems, which required modifications
in the seat:
1. When Cruz was excited, his legs stiffened and his tense
body pushed backward. So a removable ankle bar was added to keep his feet
on the footrest. The bar was made of cardboard reinforced by a flat metal
rod, bent to help position his feet. A removable foot-separator of layered
cardboard was added to help him position his feet well.
2. Although the U-shaped hip-support at times seemed to help
Cruz sit upright often he would slump or push back against the seat back.
Therefore, a low-back support of layered cardboard was added, which could
be removed once he gained better hip and back control.
A Cardboard Standing-Board for Cruz
Cruz's mother, brothers, and sister often held the boy in
a standing position, and Cruz did his best. At first his legs would stiffen
spastically in a tip-toe position. But if held quietly for a few moments
the spastic muscles would gradually relax and his feet would flatten on
the ground. Cruz's mother had brought him new, high-top shoes, which seemed
to help him position his feet better.
The PROJIMO team felt Cruz might be ready for a standing-board.
As for his special seat, they decided to use corrugated cardboard as the
primary structure. The cardboard was reinforced with wooden struts and
had a wooden base-board.
On a preliminary trial of the standing board, Cruz stood
fairly well on it. His feet rested flat on the base-board and were held
apart by the foot-holes in the vertical frame. The boy seemed delighted
with being able to stand 'independently.'
However, the boy's knees angled inwardly as he stood. He
needed something that would hold his legs straight and apart. So a leg-separator
was made by reshaping and gluing together two cardboard boxes to form
a long, thin triangle.
A big advantage to a standing frame made of cardboard is
its smooth, soft surface and its capacity to bend or sink in slightly
under pressure. The cardboard therefore provides more gentle support for
bony areas such as Cruz's knees.
In conclusion, PROJIMO's early trials with cardboard assistive
devices show great promise. The PROJIMO team still needs to improve its
technology, to create smoother, cleaner products, but the results are
remarkably functional. Cardboard has a number of advantages over other
materials: especially its low cost and the ease with which structures
can be modified and adapted to meet individual and changing needs.
HealthWrights
P.O. Box 1344
Palo Alto CA 94302
USA
Tfno:(650) 325-7500
Fax: (650) 325-1080
|
|